Harry Potter and the Secret Treasures - H.P.S.T Chapter 1736: No One is Perfect
Harry didn’t speak. He knew Hermione was right, and more importantly, he hated himself for still hoping deep down that what she said was true: that Dumbledore had truly cared about him.
“What’s going on between you two?” Sirius asked, glancing intently at the ruins of the house ahead. “I heard shouting. You weren’t arguing, were you?”
After a moment of silence, Hermione wiped away her tears and said, “Harry wants to go find Bathilda Bagshot to ask about Dumbledore’s past.”
A look of sudden understanding crossed Sirius’s face. He grasped the situation at once.
“I remember we discussed this before, Harry. Many things aren’t as you imagine.”
Harry remained silent. He didn’t really want to discuss this further with Sirius or argue with him.
Ever since the Malfoy Manor incident, he had been avoiding conflict with Sirius.
“Listen, Harry, I know what you’re thinking, but we all make mistakes. Nobody’s perfect, Dumbledore was no exception,” said Sirius, taking a deep breath. “Even James was the same.”
Harry recalled Snape’s memory in the Pensieve — that moment when his father had hoisted Snape upside down, exposing his underwear and mocking him. He felt a deep disgust for it, and it was one of the main reasons he and Sirius had argued before.
“I understand that you want to believe everyone you love is flawless,” Sirius continued. “But that doesn’t mean they have never been deeply flawed. People are complicated. You can’t judge an entire life based on a few moments. Dumbledore made mistakes when he was young — I don’t know all the details — but you have to believe me when I say that the shock I felt when I learned about them was no less than yours. But Dumbledore changed. By the time we knew him, he had already become the greatest White wizard in the world, fighting on the front lines against darkness and evil.”
“So if Voldemort changed, we should forgive him too?” said Harry dismissively. “I couldn’t do that.”
“It’s not the same. Dumbledore never did anything irreparably harmful to others. As for Voldemort, he did many things that are unforgivable to the world, and he will undoubtedly remain a scoundrel. He even wants to become an evil god to rule over mortals! That’s hardly surprising, because he stopped being human long ago,” Sirius continued. “As for your question, think about that Riddle. He just saved Ron not long ago. What do you think should be done with him?”
Harry didn’t know how to answer. He felt differently about the fifteen-year-old Riddle.
Just as Sirius had said, that boy hadn’t harmed anyone. At fifteen, he had already separated from Voldemort’s soul, gained Dumbledore’s and Evan’s approval, and had recently helped rescue Ron. In fact, he could barely even be considered a Horcrux anymore. Harry couldn’t find any reason to destroy him — no matter that he was Riddle.
But what about Riddle, then? Riddle himself was not at fault — the one who was truly to blame was Voldemort!
“But Dumbledore…” Harry faltered, not knowing how to put it. “Didn’t he cause his sister’s death?”
“I have my doubts. That woman would write anything to make her books sell. Knowing Dumbledore as I do, he wouldn’t do such a thing, not even the Dumbledore with the dark side. Harry, I love you as much as Dumbledore loved his sister. And from what I understand, it may have been precisely because of his sister’s sudden death that Dumbledore truly turned back from that path.”
“He never told me any of this.”
“Perhaps he wanted you to discover it for yourself. That has always been Dumbledore’s way — not telling everything outright, but offering guidance instead. I don’t know what the world of the dead is like, but I dare say that if Evan really went there, he would meet Dumbledore. That’s just how he is — he always appears when we need him most, offering exactly the help required,” Sirius continued. “He must have known that after he was gone, you would look into his early life. Of course you would. He didn’t hide or erase those traces, which suggests there may be things he wanted you to learn from them. And the things he left you — the Riddle, and the Resurrection Stone — may also be meant to convey something … something he believed would help you.”
Harry fell silent. He couldn’t deny that Sirius’s explanation was possible.
It reminded him of his first impression of Dumbledore during their first year, through the Philosopher’s Stone incident.
In the ward at the end of the term, Ron had once asked if Dumbledore had intentionally led Harry to these things, deliberately giving him his father’s Invisibility Cloak to guide him.
And there was the Mirror of Erised. Dumbledore had surely meant for him to see it. Harry still remembered his own answer at the time — he remembered it very clearly.
“He’s a funny man, Dumbledore. I think he sort of wanted to give me a chance. I think he knows more or less everything that goes on here, you know. I reckon he had a pretty good idea we were going to try, and instead of stopping us, he just taught us enough to help. I don’t think it was an accident he let me find out how the mirror worked. It’s almost like he thought I had the right to face Voldemort if I could. …”
Sirius’s words reminded Harry that Dumbledore had always acted this way.
It had been that way in their first year, when facing Quirrell and Voldemort plotting to steal the Resurrection Stone.
And it was the same now!
So many times, Harry felt that Dumbledore could have solved everything easily himself, yet he chose not to. Instead, he took a roundabout path, guiding Harry and Evan to act, even when it seemed unnecessary. Still, he persisted, because these were truths they had to face, and only by doing so could they grow.
The important thing wasn’t the result, but the process.
But Harry still couldn’t understand why Dumbledore had given him the Resurrection Stone.
The writing on the Golden Snitch said “I open at the close.” In other words, Dumbledore believed Harry would need the Resurrection Stone or Riddle at the last moment? What help could they offer? And when was that last moment — was it when facing Voldemort?
Harry pondered these questions. He knew very little about the Resurrection Stone; apart from the fact that it was one of the Deathly Hallows and that it could not truly bring the dead back to life, he knew nothing else.
Perhaps he should read the tale in the book Dumbledore had left for Hermione.
The last enemy that shall be destroyed is death…
Harry thought again of the inscription on his parents’ gravestone. Somewhere deep within, it felt as though he had almost grasped something, but he couldn’t quite put his finger on it.
